- Processing Talk
- Compare
- Shapeoko HDM V3 vs ED1
Carbide 3D Shapeoko HDM V3 vs Two Trees ED1
What Shapeoko HDM V3 does better (3) and where ED1 wins (5) — every spec side by side.
vs
9.1Power & cutting6.5
7.0Speed4.8
5.8Precision9.5
3.1Safety8.9
2.4Features & ease of use9.7
Why is Shapeoko HDM V3 better than ED1?
- Spindle power2,200 W vs 600 W3.7×
- Max engraving / travel speed83 mm/s vs 50 mm/s+66%
- Z travel145 mm vs 120 mm+21%
Why is ED1 better than Shapeoko HDM V3?
- Enclosed (fully covered)No · Shapeoko HDM V3: Yes
- Automatic tool changerNo · Shapeoko HDM V3: Yes
- Weight120 kg vs 38 kg3.2×
- Laser module option (CNC)No · Shapeoko HDM V3: Yes
- Tool length / Z probeNo · Shapeoko HDM V3: Yes
Specifications
Side by side
| General | ||
| Motion system | Gantry (XY rails) | Gantry (XY rails) |
| Frame material | — | Aluminium |
| Work area | ||
| Work area | — | 300 × 200 mm |
| Work area width (X) | — | 300 mm |
| Work area depth (Y) | — | 200 mm |
| Work area (surface) | — | 600 cm² |
| Z travel | 145 mm | 120 mm |
| Speed & cutting | ||
| Max engraving / travel speed | 83 mm/s | 50 mm/s |
| Precision | ||
| Positioning accuracy | — | 0.01 mm |
| Closed-loop motors / servos | No | No |
| Linear rails | Yes | Yes |
| Ball screws | Yes | Yes |
| Safety | ||
| Enclosed (fully covered) | No | Yes |
| Lid interlock | — | Yes |
| Features | ||
| Built-in camera | — | Yes |
| Rotary attachment support | — | Yes |
| Touchscreen / control panel | — | Yes |
| Water cooling | Yes | — |
| Laser module option (CNC) | No | Yes |
| Automatic tool changer | No | Yes |
| Tool length / Z probe | No | Yes |
| Connectivity & software | ||
| Connections | — | Wi-Fi |
| Wi-Fi | — | Yes |
| USB | — | Yes |
| SD / TF card | — | Yes |
| Compatible software | Carbide Create, Carbide Motion | Easel, Fusion 360 |
| Controller / firmware | — | GRBL |
| File formats | — | NC, G-code |
| CNC milling | ||
| Spindle power | 2,200 W | 600 W |
| Max spindle speed | — | 18,000 rpm |
| Collet | ER20 | — |
| Size & power | ||
| Width | — | 630 mm |
| Depth | — | 510 mm |
| Height | — | 525 mm |
| Weight | 120 kg | 38 kg |
| Rated power consumption | — | 240 W |
| Input voltage | — | 200–240 V |
