18 Nov 2026Laser & CNC machines 457Brands 30Comparisons 1,451
PROCESSINGTALKlaser cutters, engravers & CNC routers
TrendingX5 Pro ▲3018 REX ▲Ray7 20W ▲K1 3.5WS2 7WPolar 2 70WEffi9S 90WRay7S 7.5WReno Pro&Vision 65W
  1. Processing Talk
  2. Compare
  3. Nomad 4 vs A1S

Carbide 3D Nomad 4 vs Makera A1S

What Nomad 4 does better (0) and where A1S wins (9) — every spec side by side.

Carbide 3D Nomad 4
Carbide 3D · 2024Nomad 4
4.7Score
0 advantages≈ US$5,400
vs
Makera A1S
Makera · 2026A1S
9.2Score
9 advantages≈ US$2,600
Higher score
5.5Precision9.6
3.6Work area5.5
3.1Safety9.4
2.5Features & ease of use9.6

Why is Nomad 4 better than A1S?

Nomad 4 has no measurable advantages in this pair.

Why is A1S better than Nomad 4?

  1. Enclosed (fully covered)No · Nomad 4: Yes
  2. Closed-loop motors / servosNo · Nomad 4: Yes
  3. Automatic tool changerNo · Nomad 4: Yes
  4. Work area (surface)516 cm² vs 600 cm²+16%
  5. Z travel95 mm vs 130 mm+36%
  6. Laser module option (CNC)No · Nomad 4: Yes
  7. Tool length / Z probeNo · Nomad 4: Yes
  8. Weight54.4 kg vs 40 kg+36%
  9. Work area width (X)254 mm vs 300 mm+18%
Specifications

Side by side

Carbide 3D Nomad 4Carbide 3D Nomad 4≈ US$5,4004.7
Makera A1SMakera A1S≈ US$2,6009.2
General
Motion systemGantry (XY rails)Gantry (XY rails)
Work area
Work area254 × 203 mm300 × 200 mm
Work area width (X)254 mm300 mm
Work area depth (Y)203 mm200 mm
Work area (surface)516 cm²600 cm²
Z travel95 mm130 mm
Speed & cutting
Max engraving / travel speed—67 mm/s
Precision
Positioning accuracy—0.01 mm
Closed-loop motors / servosNoYes
Linear railsYesYes
Ball screwsYesYes
Safety
Enclosed (fully covered)NoYes
Features
Built-in camera—Yes
Rotary attachment support—Yes
Offline engraving (no computer)—Yes
Laser module option (CNC)NoYes
Automatic tool changerNoYes
Tool length / Z probeNoYes
Connectivity & software
Connections—USB, Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi—Yes
USB—Yes
Compatible softwareVectric VCarveFusion 360, Vectric VCarve
CNC milling
Spindle power—600 W
Max spindle speed24,000 rpm24,000 rpm
ColletER16—
Size & power
Weight54.4 kg40 kg
To compare: 0up to 4 models
Compare